Wednesday, March 25, 2009

The Dark Hills Divide

Twelve-year-old Alexa Daley lives in a world that is entirely bordered by walls - enormous, looming walls, that are supposed to keep the townspeople safe from lurking evils from the forests outside. Most people are unsettled by the thought of what lies beyond the walls, but not Alexa. In fact, when she accompanies her father on their annual visit to the town of Bridewell, the thing she is most excited about is the fact that from the window of her bedchamber, she can catch a glimpse of the world beyond the walls. This year she's particularly thrilled because she has "borrowed" her mother's spyglass so she can get a better view.

Alexa loves being in Bridewell because her father (the mayor of a nearby city) is usually too busy to pay much attention to her because of his duties, and that means she can explore to her heart's content. Her special friends include the librarian, Grayson, and Warvold, the founder of Bridewell itself. She has one enemy at Bridewell, an unpleasant guardsman named Pervis Kotcher, who has an abiding dislike for her and tries to thwart her at every turn. This summer, though, an unexpected turn of events, coupled with an astonishing discovery, leads to Alexa finally being able to realize her dream of going outside the walls. What she finds there is almost too much for a twelve-year-old to bear, as Alexa finds that she is the only one with the knowledge to prevent a catastrophe from befalling Bridewell.

This was an interesting beginning to a middle-grade fantasy series. Alexa is a character who is very alone - she moves in an entirely adult world, and never appears to see another child during the entire course of the book. Her character is compelling, and events move swiftly from one exciting or intriguing scene to the next - and because of this I believe younger readers will be swept up in the story and perhaps not have some of the questions that remained with me at the end of the book. I wondered at the timing, for example. It seemed a bit contrived that Alexa should happen upon a way out of the walls by chance, only to find that time is running out and a conspiracy is about to culminate a plan that's been years and years in the making that she is just in time to try to thwart. There was no apparent reason for the conspirators to have waited so many years to initiate their dire plans, at least not that I could see.

Children who love books in which animals are characters, such as the Narnia and Redwall series, are sure to find this appealing. I found the little squirrel to be particularly charming, in a manically heroic sort of way. There are many other appealing elements as well, including trapdoors and secret passages, mysterious stones with puzzles in them, and confusing prophecies. The concept of walling out parts of our world for various reasons is an intriguing one that offers young readers fodder for discussion and thought.

This is my first read for the Once Upon a Time III challenge.

Books in the Land of Elyon series:
1. The Dark Hills Divide
2. Beyond the Valley of Thorns
3. The Tenth City
4. Into the Mist

The Dark Hills Divide (#1 in the Land of Elyon series) by Patrick Carman; narrated by Aasne Vigesaa (Brilliance Audio, 2005)

Also reviewed at:
Jen Robinson's Book Page: "Overall, I think that this book will appeal to younger fans of fantasy novels. The plot has plenty of twists and turns, and the atmosphere varies from brooding menace to magical possibility."
A Patchwork of Books: "...this book is somewhat similar to a lot of other fantasy/adventure novels that I've read. However, it had many of its own quirks and original aspects that made it enjoyable to read and allow me to get involved enough to want to know what happens in the next book!"


  1. I was a big fan of Redwall as a kid, so liking the sound of this one. And it’s a great cover!

  2. Ooh! I had not heard of this series until now. Thank you, I have to check it out!!

  3. As a librarian, I love that a librarian is a character.

  4. Mariel - I'll be curious to hear what you think of it!

    Cat - you are welcome. I kept running across it and was tantalized by that cover. I had the audio book lined up on my iPod back when I reviewed this same author's Skeleton Creek a couple months ago and hadn't even realized they were written by the same person!

    Lisa B. - Me, too! And I love big old mysterious libraries in books, too. Particularly the one in Garth Nix's Lirael. I love to spend some time in THAT library!

  5. Pretty much the same as Mariel (you like her Redwall inspired name?). I still love the Redwall books though and am looking forward to re-reading the whole series soon.

  6. Rhinoa - I hadn't realized that about Mariel's name, but I get it now. Cool! :-) It will be fun to read reviews of your rereads.

  7. Yep that's me, Mariel of Redwall! I'd love to start rereading them too.

  8. Mariel - The first Redwall is one of my planned books to read to the kids some time soon. I know once I read the first one, they'll be all over the rest of the series. Have you read the Warriors books? Those are very popular at my library among Redwall fans, and I've been meaning to try them at some point. There are just so many of them in the series (with different sub-series, etc.) that it's a bit daunting, but one of these days...

  9. Are they the warrior cats books? I heard something about them recently and forgot to ask about the author! Intrigued...

  10. Mariel - Yes, it's the warrior cats. The author is Erin Hunter. They are incredibly popular at my library!

  11. The cover art of this series always catches my eye, and I would like to read them someday. Great review!

  12. Shelley - I think that's why I picked this up in the first place. I kept seeing that intriguing cover. Hope you enjoy it!


Thanks for stopping by and taking the time to leave a comment!